Lighting Values / Bloom | Blown out

🌵 Needle Engine
1

Hi! I’m new here.

So I’m digging around and I can’t find anything specific to this (or maybe I’m just searching wrong?) But I’m running into an issue where bloom / lighting values are getting blown out harshly with Needle. (Left is browser/player)

Any idea what could cause this?

image.png
image.png1820×901 181 KB

Original Post on Discord

by user 183299397281513483

2

Could this be HDRP specific?
Here’s the same scene in SRP

image.png
image.png1067×495 62.2 KB

by user 183299397281513483

3

Hello David, HDRP uses more realistic light values, our testing is currently focused on URP and BiRP

4

Could you switch to URP in your project?

5

I was just doing that… SRP and URP both have a similar result here.
image.png

image.png
image.png736×765 73.4 KB

by user 183299397281513483

6

The bloom effect doesn’t present at all

by user 183299397281513483

7

By the way thanks for looking into this. I’m sure it’s something simple I’m missing here.

by user 183299397281513483

8

So with HDRP lights are blown up.
With URP Bloom seems disabled
SRP same thing.

by user 183299397281513483

9

What do you mean by SRP? It refers to the system URP and HDRP are built with (Scriptable Render Pipeline)

Can you show the bloom settings in your volume?
Looks like it does something in the right image but slightly different? So maybe tweaking theshold/intensity/scatter a bit would help?

10

OK, so, I’m still getting used to the hierarchy requirement for SceneRoot, so that’s my bad.

This is how it presents when I don’t mess that part up >_<

image.png
image.png675×874 80.2 KB

image.png
image.png1006×709 101 KB

image.png
image.png893×645 85.3 KB

by user 183299397281513483

11

This is URP fwiw

by user 183299397281513483

12

Compared to what I saw with HDRP, it’s similar

by user 183299397281513483

13

and yeah I meant built-in RP not SRP before.

by user 183299397281513483

14

Ah so it was outside the glb? Ok :slightly_smiling_face: mh yea the effect doesnt match exactly what unity does. Can you try if you can get to a satisfying result with adjusting intensity/theshold/scatter?

15

Good enough for now I suppose.
Left is editor, right is browser

image.png
image.png501×533 58.6 KB

image.png
image.png688×695 149 KB

by user 183299397281513483

16

I’ll work around it for now. Thanks for looking into this.

by user 183299397281513483

17

Great. Hopefully we can get it closer to what you see in Unity over time. Adding support for these PP effects is a relatively new feature

18

I get that. Unity themselves can’t even align values between render pipelines so I didn’t fully expect parallel support out of the box. I try to be realistic :smile:

by user 183299397281513483

19

Thanks again! Excited to get building. But for now I do a sleep.

by user 183299397281513483